Satoshi and WikiLeaks: "Kicked the Hornet's Nest" (December 2010)
In December 2010 Satoshi Nakamoto publicly asked WikiLeaks not to use Bitcoin. On 5 December he wrote on Bitcointalk, "No, don't 'bring it on'… I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin." Six days later, on 11 December 2010 at 23:39 UTC, he added the line people still quote: "WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest, and the swarm is headed towards us." The next day he made his last public forum post. WikiLeaks did not start taking bitcoin until 14 June 2011.
Satoshi and WikiLeaks at a glance
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 28 Nov 2010 | WikiLeaks begins publishing US diplomatic cables ("Cablegate") |
| 3–4 Dec 2010 | PayPal cuts off the account used for WikiLeaks donations |
| 4 Dec 2010 | Forum user RHorning writes "Basically, bring it on" about WikiLeaks using bitcoin |
| 5 Dec 2010, 09:08 UTC | Satoshi replies: "No, don't 'bring it on'" |
| 6–7 Dec 2010 | Mastercard and Visa stop processing payments to WikiLeaks |
| 11 Dec 2010, 23:39 UTC | Satoshi: "WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest" |
| 12 Dec 2010 | Satoshi's last Bitcointalk post (release notes for Bitcoin 0.3.19) |
| 14 Jun 2011 | WikiLeaks tweets that it now accepts anonymous Bitcoin donations |
Why WikiLeaks needed another way to get paid
At the end of November 2010 WikiLeaks started publishing leaked US State Department cables with partner newspapers. Within days, the companies that moved its money pulled out. WikiLeaks' own timeline of what it called the "banking blockade" lists PayPal discontinuing service on 3 December, Visa and Mastercard stopping payments by 7 December, Bank of America on 18 December and Western Union on 21 December. The Guardian's running timeline from that week dates the PayPal restriction to 4 December and Mastercard to 6 December.
For the small Bitcoin forum, the story was obvious: here was a famous organization being cut off by every payment network at once, and here was a payment system no company could switch off. Some members wanted to invite WikiLeaks in.
"No, don't bring it on": the 5 December 2010 reply
The thread was titled Wikileaks contact info?. On 4 December 2010 the user RHorning wrote: "Basically, bring it on. Let's encourage Wikileaks to use Bitcoins and I'm willing to face any risk or fallout from that act."
Satoshi answered the next morning, 5 December 2010 at 09:08 UTC:
No, don't "bring it on".
The project needs to grow gradually so the software can be strengthened along the way.
I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin. Bitcoin is a small beta community in its infancy. You would not stand to get more than pocket change, and the heat you would bring would likely destroy us at this stage.
His argument was practical, not political. Bitcoin was under two years old, the 0.3.x client still labeled itself "beta," and in August 2010, only a few months earlier, the network had needed an emergency fix for the 184 billion bitcoin overflow bug. In his view, attention from governments would arrive before the software could take it.
"Kicked the hornet's nest": the 11 December 2010 post
On 10 December 2010, PC World published Keir Thomas's article "Could the Wikileaks Scandal Lead to New Virtual Currency?," which discussed Bitcoin as a way around the payment-service cuts. In the forum thread PC World Article on Bitcoin, Satoshi posted on 11 December 2010 at 23:39:16 UTC:
It would have been nice to get this attention in any other context. WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest, and the swarm is headed towards us.
That is the whole post: two sentences. He did not blame WikiLeaks or praise it. He said he would have preferred the attention "in any other context."
What happened right after
On 12 December 2010, the day after the hornet's nest post, Satoshi published his last Bitcointalk message, the release notes for Bitcoin 0.3.19, which added denial-of-service limits and removed "safe mode" alerts. The next day he announced the same release on the bitcoin-list mailing list. He kept emailing a few developers until April 2011, which we cover in Satoshi's last message, but he made no further forum posts.
The timing is why many people connect the two events. In the writings we have, Satoshi never said WikiLeaks was why he stepped back, so that remains a theory, not a documented fact. What the public posts from those days do show is that he was worried about this kind of attention.
When WikiLeaks finally accepted bitcoin
WikiLeaks waited about six months. On 14 June 2011 it tweeted: "WikiLeaks now accepts anonymous Bitcoin donations on 1HB5XMLmzFVj8ALj6mfBsbifRoD4miY36v." Forbes covered the announcement the same day and noted that Visa, Mastercard and Bank of America had all cut off donations over the previous six months.
By then Satoshi was gone, and the network he had asked to "grow gradually" had to handle the attention without him.
Why this moment still matters
The WikiLeaks episode is one of the clearest real-world cases of the problem Bitcoin was designed for. The whitepaper Introduction opens: "Commerce on the Internet has come to rely almost exclusively on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties to process electronic payments." In December 2010 those third parties showed they could shut off payments to an organization in under a week. The genesis block embeds the 3 January 2009 Times headline "Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks"; the hornet's nest line was about what happens when that idea meets the real world.
It also shows Satoshi's priorities. With an easy chance at publicity, he asked for less attention, not more, and put the software first.
If that's the part of Bitcoin's story you care about, our Genesis T-shirt carries the block that started it, and the Whitepaper T-shirt carries the document behind it. See all designs on our Bitcoin T-shirts page.
Satoshi and WikiLeaks: quick facts
What did Satoshi say about WikiLeaks?▼
On 5 December 2010 he wrote "No, don't 'bring it on'" and appealed to WikiLeaks not to use Bitcoin because it was "a small beta community in its infancy." On 11 December 2010 he wrote, "WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest, and the swarm is headed towards us."
When did Satoshi post the hornet's nest quote?▼
On 11 December 2010 at 23:39 UTC on Bitcointalk, in a thread about a PC World article on Bitcoin.
Did WikiLeaks use bitcoin in 2010?▼
No. WikiLeaks announced it was accepting bitcoin donations on 14 June 2011, about six months after Satoshi's appeal.
Why did Satoshi not want WikiLeaks to use Bitcoin?▼
He said the project needed to grow gradually so the software could be strengthened, that WikiLeaks would get "pocket change," and that "the heat you would bring would likely destroy us at this stage."
Is WikiLeaks the reason Satoshi disappeared?▼
Nobody knows. His last Bitcointalk post came one day after the hornet's nest message, and his last known emails were in April 2011, but he never gave WikiLeaks as a reason.
Wear the history
MOOD prints moments you can date and verify. The Genesis T-shirt carries the block that started it; the Whitepaper T-shirt carries the document behind it. See all designs on our Bitcoin T-shirts page.
Shop the Genesis T-shirtSources
- WikiLeaks, Cablegate: 250,000 US Embassy Diplomatic Cables (publication began 28 Nov 2010)
- Bitcointalk, RHorning in Wikileaks contact info? (4 Dec 2010)
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, Re: Wikileaks contact info?, 5 Dec 2010 (quotes RHorning's "bring it on" lines)
- Keir Thomas, Could the Wikileaks Scandal Lead to New Virtual Currency?, PC World, 10 Dec 2010
- Bitcointalk thread, PC World Article on Bitcoin
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, Re: PC World Article on Bitcoin, 11 Dec 2010
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, Added some DoS limits, removed safe mode (0.3.19), 12 Dec 2010, 18:22:33 UTC (last Bitcointalk post)
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, "[bitcoin-list] Bitcoin 0.3.19 is released", 13 Dec 2010
- Bitcoin Core, version label "version %s%s beta" in the 12 Dec 2010 0.3.19-era tree
- Mike Hearn, email thread including Satoshi's 23 Apr 2011 reply
- Gavin Andresen, Eleven years ago today… (publishes the 26 Apr 2011 alert-key email; archived)
- Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, Introduction
- WikiLeaks, Banking Blockade and Donations Campaign information pack
- The Guardian, WikiLeaks under attack: the definitive timeline (7 Dec 2010)
- WikiLeaks tweet, 14 Jun 2011 (archived)
- Forbes, WikiLeaks Asks For Anonymous Bitcoin Donations (14 Jun 2011)
Share